A New Age of Inquisition?
Since the medieval court jester and the traveling Punch and Judy shows, comedy and satire have been ways of confronting political corruption. Late night television carries that tradition forward.
Yesterday it was “Last Week
Tonight” host John Oliver who got my attention with a troubling reminder of
Alligator Alcatraz, the ill-conceived and now-closed immigration detention
facility in the Florida Everglades opened by outgoing Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis.
Oliver said the closed facility was “still very much worth talking about.”
“For one thing, alligator
Alcatraz is a pretty good encapsulation of the performative cruelty of Trump’s
second term,” he said.
Oliver referenced “all the
costs, human and otherwise, that should be reckoned with going forward,” including
detailed reports of inhumane conditions and guards allegedly beating detainees.
He reviewed how many of those being held were far from “the most vicious
people” Trump had claimed would be sent to the facility, and how the estimated
cost ballooned to near $1 billion.
He wrapped up with, “Even
though it’s now closed, we should make sure that we remember the utter disgrace
that it was. Everybody involved with Alligator Alcatraz should have the shame
of it stick to them for the rest of their lives because it was a shoddy,
shameless attempt to gain political points with public cruelty.”
While the facility itself was
indefensible, that last phrase ambushed me: “…to gain political points with public
cruelty.” On the Internet and cable TV I watch a daily increase—in occasions
or in awareness of those occasions; probably some of both—of that “public
cruelty.” From almost weekly brawls at football games (on and off the field) to
verbal belligerence on social media, public cruelty is paraded before us with growing
hostility and violence growing out of an intolerance of differences.
And to intentionally appeal to that mindset in order to gain political favor is unconscionable.
A nation midwifed into
existence by enlightenment thinking—“conceived in liberty and dedicated to the proposition
that all men (sic) are created equal”[1]—is sliding into the grip of a
subculture regressing into a pre-enlightenment feudal culture rigidly
controlled by religious terror and political oligarchy and enforced with
violence if necessary. It is a subculture comfortable with restricting the
rights of any who disagree.
Images of Inquisition—burnings
at the stake and witch hunts with hooded Inquisitors stalking the territory in
search of heretics and infidels (all those who disagree with the established norms
and values)—may not be completely irrelevant if the growing intolerance of
differences morphs into the power to enforce compliance with the values and
policies of whoever is in power this week.
Those images, unrealistic thought
they may be—today—are a major reason I found disturbing truth in John Oliver’s appeal
that Alligator Alcatraz is “still very much worth talking about.”
That’s the way it looks
through the Flawed Glass that is my world view.
Together in the Walk,
Jim
Comments
Post a Comment